The One That Got Away

S01E05 Really, Portal?! Really!?

During the lively pool party, The Portal reactivates for Jeff and Kasey. Jeff encounters a coworker who harbors feelings for him, while Kasey’s goofy neighbor from her hometown is eager to pursue romance. The Arrivals manage to persuade Taylor that Ashley could be a potential threat. Meanwhile, Vince’s relationship with one of his Arrivals soars, igniting jealousy among the others in the house. In the end, Allyssa reaches her breaking point when The Portal introduces her to an Arrival that doesn’t meet her expectations.